file, READ-LINE

Dealing with newlines

Comment

rationale

OF implementation

Suggested reference implementation

Session timer and preseving contributions

Example

core-ext-s-should-reference-file-ext-s-

Core-ext S\" should reference File-ext S\"

Proposal

file, BIN

Text mode is a bad idea for file opening

Comment

usage

Bug in 3.4.1.3

Example

bl-rationale-is-wrong

BL rationale is wrong

Proposal

core, PARSE-NAME

Space delimiters and white space

Comment

clarify-find

Clarify FIND

Proposal

tools, NAMEtoCOMPILE

NAME>COMPILE result

Comment

find-name

find-name

Proposal

revise-rationale-of-buffer-

Revise Rationale of Buffer:

Proposal

case-insensitivity

Case insensitivity

Proposal

tools, SYNONYM

Reference implementation of SYNONYM

Suggested reference implementation

tools, SYNONYM

Test cases for SYNONYM

Suggested Testcase

input-values-other-than-true-and-false

Input values other than true and false

Proposal

nestable-recognizer-sequences

Nestable Recognizer Sequences

Proposal

traverse-wordlist-does-not-find-unnamed-unfinished-definitions

Traverse-wordlist does not find unnamed/unfinished definitions

Proposal

reword-the-term-execution-token-

Reword the term "execution token"

Proposal

emit-and-non-ascii-values

EMIT and non-ASCII values

Proposal

reference-implementations-are-not-normative

Reference implementations are not normative

Proposal

string, CMOVE

CMOVE implementation based on MOVE

Suggested reference implementation

specify-that-0-throw-pops-the-0

Specify that 0 THROW pops the 0

Proposal

file, READ-LINE

Some clarifications

Comment

xchar, XSTRINGMinus

Pronounciation

Comment

float, StoF

Pronounciation

Example

float, FtoS

Pronounciation

Comment

double, DUless

Pronounciation

Comment

xchar, MinusTRAILING-GARBAGE

Pronounciation

Comment

xchar, PlusXDivSTRING

Pronounciation

Comment

pronounciations

Pronounciations

Proposal

tools, SYNONYM

Etymology of SYNONYM

Comment

core, WORD

WORD and the text interpreter

Request for clarification

Proposals and the document

Comment

CfVs after committee decision

Comment

In the list of contributions and replies by a person, please link to the contribution or reply

Comment

special-memory-access-words

Special memory access words

Proposal

core, BL

ASCII version of BL

Suggested reference implementation

core, RECURSE

proposal: recurse' to complement recurse

Comment

core, Tick

Request for clarification

core, ENDCASE

Proposal: end-case

Comment

usage

3.3.3.5 Input buffer: "A program shall not write into the input buffer."

Comment

core, UNLOOP

Another use of UNLOOP

Suggested Testcase

tools, TRAVERSE-WORDLIST

TRAVERSE-WORDLIST is in the wrong word set

Comment

wlscope-wordlists-switching-made-easier

WLSCOPE -- wordlists switching made easier

Proposal

float

Mistake in the specification of significand?

Example

defer-this-not-

DEFER this not :-)

Proposal

tools, SYNONYM

Incomplete specification of SYNONYM

Comment

directory-experiemental-proposal

Directory experiemental proposal

Proposal

implementations-requiring-both-32-bit-single-floats-and-64-bit-double-floats-

Implementations requiring BOTH 32 bit single floats and 64 bit double floats.

Proposal

core-ext-s-should-reference-file-ext-s-

Core-ext S\" should reference File-ext S\"

Proposal

the-value-of-state-should-be-restored

The value of STATE should be restored

Proposal

bl-rationale-is-wrong

BL rationale is wrong

Proposal

exception-locals

EXCEPTION LOCALs

Proposal

core, TYPE

Suggested reference implementation

Suggested reference implementation

core, BracketTick

Suggested reference implementation

Suggested reference implementation

core, BracketCHAR

Suggested reference implementation

Suggested reference implementation

core, HEX

Suggested reference implementation

Suggested reference implementation

core, INVERT

Successful test cases would be good

Suggested Testcase

clarify-find

Clarify FIND

Proposal

tools, NAMEtoCOMPILE

NAME>COMPILE result

Comment

find-name

find-name

Proposal

tighten-the-specification-of-synonym-version-1-

Tighten the specification of SYNONYM (version 1)

Proposal

let-us-adopt-the-gerry-jackson-test-suite-as-part-of-forth-200x

Let us adopt the Gerry Jackson test suite as part of Forth 200x

Proposal

s-request-for-discussion-revised-2018-08-16-

S( "Request for Discussion" (revised 2018-08-16)

Proposal

core, BUFFERColon

the confusing names

Request for clarification

search, ALSO

ALSO without VOCABULARY

Request for clarification

core, TO

Should TO be findable?

Request for clarification

tools, BracketELSE

[if] and [else] parse white space - including comments

Request for clarification

f-r-and-fr-to-support-dynamically-scoped-floating-point-variables

F>R and FR> to support dynamically-scoped floating point variables

Proposal

core, QUIT

The reference implementation is incorrect

Suggested reference implementation

core, ACCEPT

Behavior at end of line and end of data

Request for clarification

core, CHAR

Behavior when no text found

Comment

core, ACCEPT

Receiving a zero-length string

Request for clarification

core, PlusLOOP

Numeric overflow/underflow

Request for clarification

core, Plus

Overflow/underflow

Request for clarification

notation

Terminology and wording regarding "dictionary"

Request for clarification

core, EXIT

execution of exit

Request for clarification

core, num

Cell width for numbers

Request for clarification

string, UNESCAPE

Etymology and naming issue

Request for clarification

tools, BracketDEFINED

The case of undefined interpretation semantics

Request for clarification

core, COMPILEComma

Interpretation semantics

Comment

tools, NAMEtoINTERPRET

How can the zero result be used in a Standard program?

Request for clarification

notation

What is a standard program

Comment

revise-rationale-of-buffer-

Revise Rationale of Buffer:

Proposal

core, BUFFERColon

Address between runs

Request for clarification

core, PARSE-NAME

Etymology and naming convention issue

Comment

tools, BracketIF

POSTPONE [IF]

Request for clarification

executing-compilation-semantics

Executing compilation semantics

Proposal

core, TO

Ambiguous conditions

Request for clarification

core, Tick

Ambiguous condition in case of undefined execution semantics

Comment

exception, CATCH

The specification of CATCH

Request for clarification

core, POSTPONE

Ambiguous condition could be removed

Comment

core, BL

Test example numeric base?

Request for clarification

right-justified-text-output

Right-justified text output

Proposal

core, EVALUATE

SOURCE-ID and nesting EVALUATE

Request for clarification

core

GNU C RESTRICT would make sense in the standard

Suggested reference implementation

block, EVALUATE

When to set BLK to zero?

Request for clarification

block, LOAD

Getting the block contents

Request for clarification

block, LIST

Does LIST transfer data to any buffer?

Request for clarification

tools

description of "nt" in the standard

Request for clarification

file, REFILL

Ambiguous conditions

Request for clarification

core, IMMEDIATE

Ambiguous conditions

Comment

cs-drop-revised-2019-08-22-

CS-DROP (revised 2019-08-22)

Proposal

case-insensitivity

Case insensitivity

Proposal

remove-the-rules-of-find-

Remove the “rules of FIND”

Proposal

vocabulary

VOCABULARY

Proposal

tools, TRAVERSE-WORDLIST

Unfindable definitions

Comment

tools, SYNONYM

Reference implementation of SYNONYM

Suggested reference implementation

string, REPLACES

wording - "current region" term is undefined

Comment

core, RECURSE

Why RECURSE is needed?

Request for clarification

input-values-other-than-true-and-false

Input values other than true and false

Proposal

better-wording-for-colon

Better wording for Colon

Proposal

name-interpret-wording

NAME>INTERPRET wording

Proposal

core, Colon

The parts of execution semantics and the calling definition

Request for clarification

recognizer-rfd-rephrase-2020

Recognizer RfD rephrase 2020

Proposal

core, p

"(" typo in a testcase

Comment

wording-declare-undefined-interpretation-semantics-for-locals

Wording: declare undefined interpretation semantics for locals

Proposal

core, StoD

Word set of S>D word

Request for clarification

same-name-token-for-different-words

Same name token for different words

Proposal

locals

Recognizer for locals

Comment

core, SMDivREM

There is error in testing

Comment

core, DEFER

Defer Implementation

Comment

recognizer

Recognizer

Proposal

tools, SYNONYM

Does the wording of the rules imply that if you SYNONYM a word with the same name in the same wordlist and then 'look it up', you will get the old word?

Request for clarification

core, PARSE

What happens when parse reaches the end of the parse area and the parse delimiter was not found?

Request for clarification

testsuite

Please fix word spelling in F.1 second paragraph second word.

Suggested reference implementation

2020-forth-standards-meeting-agenda

2020 Forth Standards meeting agenda

Proposal

rationale

Annex A section and paragraph numbering has gone wrong

Request for clarification

optional-ieee-754-binary-floating-point-word-set

OPTIONAL IEEE 754 BINARY FLOATING-POINT WORD SET

Proposal

nestable-recognizer-sequences

Nestable Recognizer Sequences

Proposal

tools

Getting execution semantics from nt

Request for clarification

traverse-wordlist-does-not-find-unnamed-unfinished-definitions

Traverse-wordlist does not find unnamed/unfinished definitions

Proposal

xml-forth-standard-migration-from-latex-to-docbook

XML Forth Standard - migration from LaTeX to DocBook

Proposal

call-for-vote-ambiguous-condition-in-16-3-3

Call for Vote - Ambiguous condition in 16.3.3

Proposal

interpretation-semantic-for-locals-are-undefined

Interpretation semantic for locals are undefined

Proposal

reword-the-term-execution-token-

Reword the term "execution token"

Proposal

licence-to-use-reference-implementations

Licence to use reference implementations

Proposal

an-alternative-to-the-recognizer-proposal

An alternative to the RECOGNIZER proposal

Proposal

minimalistic-core-api-for-recognizers

minimalistic core API for recognizers

Proposal

tick-and-undefined-execution-semantics

Tick and undefined execution semantics

Proposal

search, DEFINITIONS

off-by-one error in reference implementation

Suggested reference implementation

usage

Data type for strings

Comment

core, TwoStore

Cells numeration in a cell-pair

Comment

exception, THROW

THROW: text doesn't match implementation example

Comment

core, SOURCE-ID

Should this reference the optional word sets where SOURCE-ID is changed

Example

core, SOURCE

Relationship to block set

Example

core, BracketCOMPILE

Obsoleted - by what?

Request for clarification

core, Tick

Is Tick Immediate?

Request for clarification

core, POSTPONE

Needs an example of replacing COMPILE

Example

locals, bColon

Run-Time Section is Missing Words

Comment

block, BLOCK

Can `BLOCK` transfer from mass storage in the case when block u is already in a block buffer?

Request for clarification

block, BLOCK

Can `BLOCK` transfer from mass storage in the case when block u is already in a block buffer?

Request for clarification

core, COUNT

Is a counted string limited to 255 chars?

Request for clarification

core, num

Note incompatability (double v single) with some older Forth's.

Comment

usage

Size of implementation dependent data types

Request for clarification

emit-and-non-ascii-values

EMIT and non-ASCII values

Proposal

core, LEAVE

Stack effect of LEAVE during compilation

Request for clarification

core, DEFERStore

Does the standard assume that DEFER was created with CREATE?

Request for clarification

reference-implementations-are-not-normative

Reference implementations are not normative

Proposal

core, ALLOT

ALLOT in ROMable systems

Request for clarification

core, BracketCOMPILE

How to avoid default compilation semantics in the specification for [COMPILE]

Comment

string, COMPARE

How many cells can be compared ? Must have any limit ?

Request for clarification

core, CComma

Additional test for UTF-16

Suggested Testcase

xchar, XC-WIDTH

Return value of XC-WIDTH for control characters

Request for clarification

right-bracket

Web site problem?

Request for clarification

double, DtoS

Inaccurate Test Cases?

Suggested Testcase

wording-change-for-compile-harmonization-with-terms

Wording change for "COMPILE,": harmonization with terms

Proposal

tools, SYNONYM

Portable implementation for SYNONYM

Suggested reference implementation

string, DivSTRING

Possible Reference Implementation

Suggested reference implementation

double, TwoVALUE

Mistake in implementation?

Comment

core, Bracket

Why "[" is specified using immediacy?

Request for clarification

place-place

PLACE +PLACE

Proposal

core, DEPTH

More general Testcase

Suggested Testcase

2021-standards-meeting-agenda

2021 Standards meeting agenda

Proposal

string, CMOVE

CMOVE implementation based on MOVE

Suggested reference implementation

tick-and-undefined-execution-semantics-2

Tick and undefined execution semantics - 2

Proposal

specify-that-0-throw-pops-the-0

Specify that 0 THROW pops the 0

Proposal

better-wording-for-data-field-term

Better wording for "data field" term

Proposal

better-wording-for-glossary-notation-

Better wording for "Glossary notation"

Proposal

file, READ-LINE

Some clarifications

Comment

core, EVALUATE

New Line characters in a string passed to EVALUATE

Example

core, TwoSWAP

Implement with ROT

Suggested reference implementation

agenda-forth-200x-interim-meeting-2020-02-18t14-00z

Agenda Forth-200x interim Meeting 2020-02-18T14:00Z

Proposal

double, DZeroEqual

Using a . suffix to specify a double

Comment

core, Cq

c-addr used in stack diagrams

Request for clarification

locals

Contradiction With do-loops

Request for clarification

search, FORTH-WORDLIST

inconsistent naming

Request for clarification

core, UMTimes

Question about final test

Request for clarification

core, MTimes

Double>

Request for clarification

core, VARIABLE

Possible Reference Implementation

Suggested reference implementation

usage

Same execution token

Request for clarification

core, RFetch

Suggested reference implementation

formatting-spaces-in-data-type-symbols

Formatting: spaces in data type symbols

Proposal

exclude-zero-from-the-data-types-that-are-identifiers

Exclude zero from the data types that are identifiers

Proposal

double, DUless

Pronounciation

Comment

core, QUIT

Should QUIT propagate exceptions?

Request for clarification

exception

Exception word set is not optional any more

Comment

pronounciations

Pronounciations

Proposal

test-proposal

Test Proposal

Proposal

doc

Seemingly contradictory ambiguous condition?

Request for clarification

core, CHAR

Describe Compile time and Run time behavior

Comment

doc

Comment

relax-documentation-requirements-of-ambiguous-conditions

Relax documentation requirements of Ambiguous Conditions

Proposal

core, d

Suggested reference implementation

core, PICK

Example implementation for PICK

Suggested reference implementation

tools, NtoR

Bad Stack Notation?

Comment

core, SAVE-INPUT

Is data stack required?

Request for clarification

exception, THROW

Input source after THROW

Comment

core, ENVIRONMENTq

First testcase broken

Suggested Testcase

agenda-forth-200x-interim-meeting-2023-02-17t15-00z

Agenda Forth-200x interim Meeting 2023-02-17T15:00Z

Proposal

core, RECURSE

Tail call elimination

Comment

update-rationale-for-sliteral

Update rationale for SLITERAL

Proposal

file, p

Multi-line ( behavior

Request for clarification

2c-and-2c-

2C! and 2C@

Proposal

16-bit-memory-access

16-bit memory access

Proposal

implementation standards

Suggested reference implementation

2023-standards-meeting-agenda-2023-09-13-to-2023-09-15-

2023 Standards meeting agenda (2023-09-13 to 2023-09-15)

Proposal

fix-stack-comments-for-n-r-and-nr-

Fix stack comments for N>R and NR>

Proposal

test

Test

Proposal

core, WORD

WORD and the text interpreter

Request for clarification

search, SEARCH-WORDLIST

NDCS xt

Request for clarification

tools, TRAVERSE-WORDLIST

Nested invocation, ret stack

Request for clarification

search, SET-ORDER

Negative n values

Request for clarification

tools, NAMEtoINTERPRET

NAME<INTERPRET, NAME>TO, NAME<TO

Request for clarification

core, DROP

stack checking

Suggested reference implementation

core, QUIT

control stack clearing?

Request for clarification

core, MARKER

WORDLIST interaction

Example

tools, TRAVERSE-WORDLIST

shadowed names

Request for clarification

search, FIND

diff from CORE FIND?

Request for clarification

core, COMPILEComma

throw code for compiling outside a definition

Request for clarification

core, Colon

are colon-defs supposed to be compiled in data space?

Request for clarification

core, QUIT

"make the user input device the input source"

Example

core, DO

loopsys in data?

Request for clarification

core, PAD

PAD alignment

Request for clarification

core, SPACES

Behavior of `0 SPACES`

Request for clarification

core, UNLOOP

Is it possible to eliminate the need for `UNLOOP`?

Request for clarification

notation

Data space seems to be used invonsistently when comparing the definitions of "character string" and "data space".

Request for clarification

core, Plus

Usage of the `n|u` data type

Request for clarification

core, CStore

Data type of a parameters in `c!`

Request for clarification

special-memory-access-words

Special memory access words

Proposal

support-for-single-line-comments-during-evaluate-

Support for single line comments during `evaluate`

Proposal

allow-the-text-interpreter-to-use-word-and-the-pictured-numeric-output

Allow the text interpreter to use `WORD` and the pictured numeric output

Proposal

float, REPRESENT

Behavior of `represent` when buffer length is zero

Request for clarification

string, DivSTRING

Unspecified ambiguous condition in /STRING

Request for clarification

core, LITERAL

compile semantics or compile action of literal word

Request for clarification

core, Colon

definion and use of colon-sys and nest-sys

Request for clarification

usage

Temporary removing system-compilation items

Request for clarification

core, ABORT

State of other stacks after ABORT

Request for clarification

core, ELSE

Resolve the forward reference orig1 using the location following the appended run-time semantics.

Comment

core, PICK

Clarification on what constitutes an ambiguous condition for this word.

Request for clarification

core, TwoTimes

Bad test case

Example

octal-prefix

Octal prefix

Proposal

core, qDO

Return Stack Notation Mildly Inaccurate

Request for clarification